Honest Vintage-Style Copper Lighter
I'm not a smoker and I don't have much need for this sort of thing in my life, but if I were going to get someone a vintage-style lighter as something of a novelty gift,this would be it. It's got a bit of a steampunk vibe and feels wonderfully hefty in the hand and pocket. It even comes in a nice wooden box and includes a carry pouch, so it's already primed for gifting to a best man, your dad, or whoever else you think will appreciate this classic-looking (and quite functional!) tool.
The lighter comes in brass ($27) and silver ($25) colors. I'm partial to the former myself, but both are very nice.